Teams should be ready to show INSPECTORS documentation of
FMV for any COMPONENTS that appear to be in the range of the $600 USD limit.
The Analog Devices IMU MXP Breakout Board, P/N ADIS16448,
does not have a published FMV. This device is considered to comply with this
rule regardless of its true FMV.
The FMV of a COTS item is its price defined by a VENDOR for
the part or an identical functional replacement. This price must be generally
available to all FIRST Robotics Competition teams throughout the build
and competition season (i.e. short-term sale prices or coupons do not reflect
FMV), however teams are only expected to make a good faith effort at
determining the item price and are not expected to monitor prices of ROBOT
items throughout the season. The FMV is the cost of the item itself and does
not include any duties, taxes, tariffs, shipping, or other costs that may vary
by locality.
The FMV of COTS software is the price, set by the VENDOR,
to license the software (or piece of the software) that runs on the ROBOT for
the period from Kickoff to the end of the FIRST Championship. The FMV of
software licensed free-of-cost, including through the Virtual KOP, for use on
the ROBOT is $0.
The FMV of FABRICATED parts is the value of the material
and/or labor, except for labor provided by team members (including sponsor
employees who are members of the team), members of other teams, and/or event
provided machine shops. Material costs are accounted for as the cost of any
purchasable quantity that can be used to make the individual part (i.e. the
purchasable raw material is larger than the FABRICATED part).
Example 1: A team orders a custom bracket made by a company
to the team's specification. The company’s material cost and normally charged
labor rate apply.
Example 2: A team receives a donated sensor. The company
would normally sell this item for $450 USD, which is therefore its FMV.
Example 3: A team purchases titanium tube stock for $400
USD and has it machined by a local machine shop. The machine shop is not
considered a team sponsor but donates 2 hours of expended labor anyway. The
team must include the estimated normal cost of the labor as if it were paid to
the machine shop and add it to the $400 USD.
Example 4: A team purchases titanium tube stock for $400
USD and has it machined by a local machine shop that is a recognized sponsor of
the team. If the machinists are considered members of the team, their labor
costs do not apply. The total applicable cost for the part would be $400 USD.
It is in the best interests of the teams and FIRST
to form relationships with as many organizations as possible. Recognizing
supporting companies as sponsors of, and members in, the team is encouraged,
even if the involvement of the sponsor is solely through the donation of
fabrication labor.
Example 5: A team purchases titanium tube stock for $400
USD and has it machined by another team. The total applicable cost for the part
would be $400 USD.
Example 6: A team purchases a widget at a garage sale or
online auction for $300, but it’s available for sale from a VENDOR for $700.
The FMV is $700.
If a COTS item is part of a modular system that can be
assembled in several possible configurations, then each individual module must
fit within the price constraints defined in this rule.
If the modules are designed to assemble into a single
configuration, and the assembly is functional in only that configuration, then
the total cost of the complete assembly including all modules must fit within
the price constraints defined in this rule.
In summary, if a VENDOR sells a system or a kit, a team
must use the entire system/kit FMV and not the value of its COMPONENT pieces.
Example 7: VENDOR A sells a gearbox that can be used with a
number of different gear sets, and can mate with 2 different motors they sell.
A team purchases the gearbox, a gear set, and a motor, then assembles them
together. Each part is treated separately for the purpose of determining FMV
since the purchased pieces can each be used in various configurations.
Example 8: VENDOR B sells a robotic arm assembly that a
team wants to use. However, it costs $630 USD, so they cannot use it. The
VENDOR sells the “hand”, “wrist”, and “arm” as separate assemblies, for $210
USD each. A team wishes to purchase the 3 items separately, then reassemble
them. This would not be legal, as they are really buying and using the entire
assembly, which has a Fair Market Value of $630 USD.
Example 9: VENDOR C sells a set of wheels or wheel modules
that are often used in groups of 4. The wheels or modules can be used in other
quantities or configurations. A team purchases 4 and uses them in the most
common configuration. Each part is treated separately for the purpose of
determining FMV, since the purchased pieces can be used in various
configurations.